Most like humans … a family of golden lion marmosets. Photograph: Juergen and Christine Sohns/Getty Images/Picture Press RM
I'm an expert. Many of us are. My first wife never said the word
"love" without a sneer; my present wife is a true believer. So I've
looked at love from both sides now. But if Robin Dunbar is to be
believed, I really don't know love at all.
Remember those PG Tips ads where they dressed chimpanzees as
human beings and made them drink tea? This book is rather like those ads
in that it confuses the animal and the specifically human. Why do we
kiss, it asks. To taste our potential partner's saliva and decide if
they are healthy enough to breed with, a bit like dogs sniffing at each
other. A bad taste, a bad smell and off we go with someone else.
Sometimes the truth is disturbing, but is this really why my wife and I
are still kissing after all these years? It seems to me more like a way
of having sex with our mouths – which is wonderful if you like sex, and
disgusting if you don't. It certainly isn't something a dog would do.
Dunbar
believes emotions such as love and social institutions such as marriage
are strategies to maximise the reproduction of our genes. In biological
terms, the most successful of all humans has been Genghis Khan – around
0.5% of all males alive today are descended from him and his brothers.
But the Great Khan's reproductive strategy of mass rape is something of
an aberration.
Modern societies derive from communities of
hunter-gatherers who practised serial monogamy. Love and marriage are
the emotional and social expressions of a reproductive strategy that
goes back 200,000 years or so. Why do we pair up? Not so that men can
help feed and raise children – women would do this better on their own
(the time men spent hunting was largely time wasted, unlike the time
women spent gathering). Dunbar runs through a range of biological
comparisons – wolves ("resolutely monogamous", but male wolves vomit up
food for the mother and pups; unlike many human males they really are
good dads), goats, baboons, gorillas – and concludes that we are like
marmosets. Women need husbands to protect them from being attacked by
other men. Men don't get much out of love and marriage (except, of
course, the reproduction of their genes); women get security.
But
women don't just want security. According to Dunbar (who doesn't see
that this is a major hole in his argument), all women would have needed
to do is gang together into large groups in order to defend themselves.
If only they had kicked out the worthless hunters, who didn't catch
enough to feed themselves, let alone anyone else, and only chased big
game to show off, they could have managed perfectly well. Why are there
no societies of vegetarian Amazons? Presumably because big-game hunting
was a useful way of testing men's fitness for reproduction. So love and
marriage are the result of a complicated trade off between safe sex and
exciting sex. We are marmosets who dream of being gorillas.
Dunbar
thinks dreams and fantasies only get in the way. He discusses them in
the contexts of women being ripped off by gigolos, of mystics who
believe they have been ravished by God, of de Clérambault's syndrome (
erotomania).
In other words, he's a cynic, even though he knows that the most
successful marriages are the ones where the partners idealise each
other. He discovers that our sexual partners tend to resemble our parent
of the opposite sex and he describes this as a curiosity – it never
occurs to him the Oedipus complex might be at work.
The idea that
we are different from marmosets because we idealise and fantasise,
because we kiss and laugh, read poetry and sing songs, because we are
wonderfully good at displacing our reproductive drives into all sorts of
other activities, is beyond him. American generals, Dunbar tells us,
have had fewer children than middle-ranking officers. "It was as though
they overdid themselves and went too far", is all he can say, because
naturally their real goal was not status but the replication of their
genes. They had failed the only test that counts.
"From a strictly
biological point of view," says Dunbar, "relationships exist to
facilitate reproduction." Until the 1960s the French-speaking population
of Québec was very good at reproduction, with each woman producing an
average of four children. Then along came contraception – they stopped
going to church and each woman had on average only 1.5 children.
Relationships no longer existed primarily to facilitate reproduction.
Biology had been trumped by the desire for an improved standard of
living. Instead of having children, the Québecois had cars, central
heating and holidays in Florida.
Dunbar has nothing helpful to say
about non-reproductive sex – about contraception, or homosexuality, or
even masturbation. He has little to say about happiness, and nothing at
all to say about pleasure. He prefers to talk about the relative length
of our second and fourth fingers:
a high 2D:4D ratio implies high levels of testosterone
and so polygamy or promiscuity, while a low 2D:4D ratio implies
marmoset love. Hence we can determine the family structure of
Neanderthals by measuring their finger lengths. Maybe.
This basic
confusion between humans and animals isn't the only problem with
Dunbar's work. He loves neuro-imaging. If you give psychopaths various
simple tests, different bits of their brains light up from those that
light up in the rest of the population. Consequently "psychopaths are
born and not made by circumstance." But Dunbar also tells us about
London taxi drivers. They have large hippocampuses – the bit of the
brain that deals with orientation. At first it seemed that people with
big hippocampuses become taxi drivers; but further research established
that doing "the knowledge" (studying to become a London taxi driver)
causes your hippocampus to grow. Mind/body interactions go both ways:
the fact that psychopaths' brains are different doesn't prove that
psychopaths are born and not made – it would seem perfectly plausible
that some are born, some are made, and often it's a bit of both.
In
the end, what Dunbar offers is a Darwinian reworking of traditional
sexual stereotypes. We would have to put up with this if the arguments
were robust, but they aren't. Where he is good, surprisingly, is on
intimacy, friendship and family. Lovers who touch each other a lot have
lower cortisol levels – they are less stressed. People in loving
relationships have a higher pain threshold. Laughter shared between
friends is so powerful that three letters in a text message – LOL – can
make us happy. Experimental evidence really does seem to show that
people trust their family more than they trust their friends, and that
they will make sacrifices for their family that they would not make for
their friends – since this is often a terrible mistake it is hard not to
think that this has something to do with sharing genes in common. Dogs
can count as people where friendships are concerned. We aren't wired up
to have lots of friends (Facebook notwithstanding), and one lover is
worth two friends – so people who fall in love drop two of their close
friends. Women like talking while men like doing things together – the
average phone call involving a male lasts 7.3 seconds.
When Dunbar
is talking about friendship he doesn't feel the need to look for
comparisons with other species – voles (nearly all promiscuous) and the
bee-eater bird (like marmosets, they have "an almost identical social
arrangement to humans") disappear from the story. For what makes
friendship possible is the development of "theory of mind" – "the
capacity to understand what another person is thinking" – and this is
unique to humans. Indeed we only begin to develop it after the age of
five, and go on developing it until the mid-20s. Without it we would be
unable to engage in pretend play or lying. Even our laughter is
different from that of the apes.
Strangely, he doesn't say that
without empathy there would be neither love nor betrayal. So here's the
puzzle: Dunbar understands there is something uniquely human about
friendship, but not about love. Because lovers make babies he thinks
they are just like marmosets. What Dunbar needs is a better theory of
mind. Don't misunderstand me: of course we are naked apes. Evolution
made us – up to a point. Evolution gave us a capacity for loving and
lying, for sympathy and cruelty, for displacement. But, like the taxi
drivers with the enlarged hippocampuses, we have, for better or worse,
remade ourselves. One thing is clear: love is never natural. Just as we
learn language from those around us, so we learn love – if we are lucky,
that is.
• David Wootton's
Galileo is published by Yale.